Curious Youngsters is a collection for youngsters of all ages. Have a query you’d like an skilled to reply? Ship it to CuriousKidsCanada@theconversation.com.
I do know that Putin needs to take over all of Ukraine’s land however what’s his actual motive for wanting the land? Is it for the usS.R. once more? In 1991 Ukraine formally declared itself as an unbiased nation, however why does he need the land now? Why not eight years earlier? — Annelise, 14, Cape Breton, N.S.
For a lot of centuries Russia and Ukraine have been a part of the identical nation, first as Kievan Rus after which the Russian Empire. The Russian Empire collapsed in 1917, partly as a result of some individuals residing there needed their very own international locations.
Though some Ukrainians needed independence, the brand new Soviet leaders needed to maintain Ukraine. In 1922, the Bolshevik authorities in Russia compelled Ukraine into the Soviet Union.
The Soviet Union
The Soviet Union (additionally referred to as the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, or U.S.S.R.) was a really totally different nation from the Russian Empire. It had a socialist authorities, which meant that wealth was imagined to be unfold extra evenly amongst its inhabitants than it was in Europe and North America.
The Soviet Union was in some ways extra highly effective than the Russian Empire. When Adolf Hitler’s Nazi Germany attacked the Soviet Union in June 1941, the Soviets fought onerous to cease Hitler from taking on their nation. Russians, Ukrainians and many individuals from different international locations in the usS.R. fought collectively. Some began to assume that they have been as a lot Soviet individuals as they have been Russian or Ukrainian.
After the Second World Conflict there was an extended interval of historical past generally known as the Chilly Conflict, when the Soviet Union and the western international locations like america have been in disagreement over how the world must be organized. The Soviet facet thought that an important precept was equality. The western facet thought that particular person freedoms have been extra essential.
The tip of the Soviet Union
In December 1991, the Soviet Union collapsed and broke up into smaller elements. A kind of elements was Russia, one other was Ukraine.
The usS.R. collapsed for a lot of causes together with financial issues and political combating between its leaders over whether or not it ought to proceed to be socialist or not. Within the West many leaders thought that that they had gained the Chilly Conflict as a result of the Soviet Union was now gone.
Though some have been happy that their international locations might now be separate from Russia, many have been sad that the highly effective Soviet Union had collapsed. A kind of individuals was Vladimir Putin. In 2005, when he was chief of Russia, Putin described the collapse of the Soviet Union as a “disaster.”
Putin vs. NATO
On the finish of the Chilly Conflict western leaders promised Russian leaders that international locations like Ukraine wouldn’t be a part of their navy alliance referred to as NATO, the North Atlantic Treaty Group.
However some did. Lithuania, Estonia and Latvia joined NATO in 2004. Putin wasn’t happy, and requested NATO to cease increasing its alliance. Its leaders instructed him that it was as much as the brand new international locations to determine, and that NATO wasn’t a risk to Russia. Ukraine’s leaders hoped it might be a part of NATO at some point.
(AP Picture/Mikhail Metzel)
However Putin needed former Soviet international locations to grow to be nearer to Russia as a substitute of the West. Many of those international locations have massive numbers of Russian individuals in them, and plenty of of them additionally needed to be nearer to Russia.
In 2014 Russia seized part of Ukraine referred to as Crimea that had many Russians in it. Seizing Crimea was in opposition to worldwide legislation, however Putin ordered it anyway.
In 2014-15 Russia and Ukraine held talks to attempt to kind out their variations. There have been some agreements referred to as the Minsk Accords, however neither facet was actually pleased with them and so they didn’t comply with by way of on their guarantees.
A return to the usS.R.?
In 2022, with little progress made on the Minsk agreements, Putin declared elements of Ukraine the place a number of Russians dwell to be unbiased international locations. On Feb. 24, 2022, the Russian military attacked the remainder of Ukraine.
Putin needs to forestall Ukraine from becoming a member of NATO, cease it from shifting nearer to the West and provides autonomy to some elements of the nation. He would really like Crimea to be acknowledged as a part of Russia, and Donetsk and Luhansk to be unbiased from Ukraine. However Putin has not stated that he needs all of Ukraine.
He additionally doesn’t need the usS.R. again, partly as a result of he is aware of that may’t occur. Putin will not be a socialist, so he doesn’t assume that these values of the Soviet Union are crucial.
Putin didn’t order the Russian military to invade Ukraine in 2014-15 most likely as a result of he hoped that issues may very well be sorted out with no struggle. By 2022 he might see that except he invaded Ukraine now, he wouldn’t get what he needed as a result of Ukraine may be a part of NATO sooner or later.
Hiya, curious children! Do you’ve gotten a query you’d like an skilled to reply? Ask an grownup to ship your query to CuriousKidsCanada@theconversation.com. Please inform us your identify, age and town the place you reside.
And since curiosity has no age restrict — adults, tell us what you’re questioning, too. We gained’t have the ability to reply each query, however we are going to do our greatest.
Alexander Hill doesn’t work for, seek the advice of, personal shares in or obtain funding from any firm or organisation that might profit from this text, and has disclosed no related affiliations past their educational appointment.