AP Photograph/Steven Senne
Stephen Breyer will depart a legacy that displays the Supreme Court docket he joined practically three many years in the past – much less fractious and fewer partisan than the bench he’s reportedly set to depart on the finish of the present time period.
When Breyer was nominated by Democratic President Invoice Clinton in 1994, he was not a controversial alternative. He was confirmed by an 87-9 vote within the Senate, garnering the help of 79% of Republicans.
There have been few surprises at his comparatively uneventful affirmation listening to. By and huge, senators knew what they had been getting: a average liberal who took a realistic method to judging.
For Breyer, this meant a wholesome respect for precedent and endeavoring to know the sensible penalties of the court docket’s circumstances, together with how they have an effect on the overall inhabitants.
Breyer’s majority opinions
Breyer joined a court docket that had simply reaffirmed the suitable to abortion in 1992’s Deliberate Parenthood v. Casey, and he constantly upheld the precedent set by that case and Roe v. Wade all through his tenure. In 2000, he wrote the bulk opinion in Stenberg v. Carhart, invalidating a state regulation that criminalized “partial-birth” abortion. In more moderen phrases, his opinions in Entire Girl’s Well being v. Hellerstedt and June Medical Providers, LLC v. Russo, in 2016 and 2020 respectively, struck down state hospital admission necessities for abortion clinic medical doctors.
Because the court docket moved in a extra conservative course, notably after the 2020 loss of life of liberal Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Breyer solid an alliance with Chief Justice John Roberts on the Court docket’s pragmatic middle.
Collectively, they led the court docket to average rulings upholding the Inexpensive Care Act and the free-speech rights of scholars.
Breyer’s average, pragmatic method to judging can be obvious in his dissents. As an illustration, in 2015’s Glossip v. Gross, Breyer argued that the loss of life penalty was unconstitutional as a result of it was not per modern understandings of what constitutes “merciless and strange punishment.”
To justify this, he identified that states had been more and more abandoning the loss of life penalty, that help for the loss of life penalty among the many public was reducing, and that the overwhelming majority of members of the United Nations had ceased utilizing the loss of life penalty.
Being average didn’t imply that Breyer was with out robust emotions. Within the college integration case of Dad and mom Concerned in Group Colleges v. Seattle Faculty District No. 1, which got here earlier than the court docket in 2007, Breyer learn his dissent from the bench – a uncommon prevalence that signaled his ardour for the problem.
Breyer sharply criticized the bulk’s resolution to strike down voluntary integration insurance policies aimed toward reaching racial range in a scholar physique. Lamenting what he considered as a radical departure from precedent, Breyer wrote, “It isn’t usually within the regulation that so few have so shortly modified a lot.”
Justice Breyer is a product of the period by which he was confirmed: a conservative America the place solely average Democrats had been politically viable.
[Over 140,000 readers rely on The Conversation’s newsletters to understand the world. Sign up today.]
Clinton had thought of a number of high-profile liberal politicians, together with Maine Senator George Mitchell and then-Inside Secretary Bruce Babbitt, for the Supreme Court docket seat left vacant after the retirement of Justice Harry Blackmun. However in the long run, he opted for a average choose who was already on the bench.
Breyer’s pragmatic method allowed him to achieve consensus together with his extra conservative colleagues.
His anticipated departure reminds America that the period of consensus has largely handed.
The authors don’t work for, seek the advice of, personal shares in or obtain funding from any firm or group that might profit from this text, and have disclosed no related affiliations past their tutorial appointment.