Sam Edwards/OJO Pictures through Getty Pictures
As flu season progresses, so does the refrain of recommendation, skilled and in any other case, to drink loads of fluids and take fever-reducing drugs, like acetaminophen, ibuprofen or aspirin.
These suggestions, well-intentioned and firmly entrenched, provide consolation to these sidelined with fever, flu or vaccine negative effects. However you might be stunned to study the science supporting these suggestions is speculative at greatest, dangerous at worst and comes with caveats.
I’m an train physiologist who makes a speciality of learning how the physique regulates fluids and temperature. And primarily based on a large physique of proof, I can let you know that elevated fluid consumption and taking fever reducers, whether or not aspirin, acetaminophen or ibuprofen, might not at all times assist in your restoration. In truth, in some instances, it might be dangerous.
There’s a motive why folks say fevers ought to be lowered when sick or after a vaccine. Each aspirin and acetaminophen, akin to Tylenol, scale back fever, complications and muscle aches. However on the similar time, seminal and newer research, together with broad meta-analysis research, present that these drugs might weaken the immune response to an infection or have undesirable negative effects.
What’s a fever?
First, some background: Fevers are a regulated improve in core physique temperature as a response to undesirable microbial invaders.
The extra extreme the an infection, the upper the fever.
Having a fever shouldn’t be all dangerous; it’s how the physique has developed to recuperate from an an infection. For a lot of species, fevers are advantageous and helpful for survival.
However fever comes with a value. A physique temperature that’s too excessive may be lethal. For each improve of 1.8 levels Fahrenheit, metabolism goes up 10%; the physique begins to burn extra energy than regular, temperature continues to rise and the physique releases hormones to maintain fever underneath management.
Many research display what can occur when fever reducers are thrust into this complicated dance. It seems aspirin or acetaminophen might trigger contaminated folks to really feel higher, however in addition they unfold extra virus whereas suppressing their very own immune response to the an infection.
In a single double-blind, placebo-controlled examine, wholesome folks contaminated with a chilly virus who took aspirin or acetaminophen for every week had a diminished immune response and a rise in viral shedding – that means producing and expelling virus particles from the nostril. One other examine confirmed that taking aspirin successfully diminished fever signs however elevated shedding.
Though a few of these conventional research befell many years in the past, their outcomes nonetheless maintain up in the present day. A latest examine warned that if everybody took fever suppressants, there could be much more flu instances and flu-related deaths. Moreover, elevated physique temperature – or fever – can assist battle COVID-19 by decreasing the expansion of the virus throughout the lungs. In different phrases, fevers can assist the physique battle viruses whereas decreasing the speed of loss of life and illness.
To stop dehydration, the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention recommends consuming extra fluids when one has a fever or an infection, or has obtained a COVID-19 vaccine. However there may be scant scientific proof to assist this advice.
Dina Morozova/iStock through Getty Pictures Plus
It’s true that consuming fluids when dehydrated is important to cut back fever. However not everybody with a fever is dehydrated. For individuals who aren’t thirsty, forcing fluids past thirst, which is commonly disagreeable, is probably not advisable.
[Get fascinating science, health and technology news. Sign up for The Conversation’s weekly science newsletter.]
A examine that evaluated the recommendation to “drink loads of fluids” decided that rising fluid consumption when sick might not provide advantages, and that extra high-quality research are wanted. Certainly, there was a possible threat from overhydration. For some folks, three liters, or about 12 eight-ounce glasses, is an excessive amount of. Overhydration may cause nausea and vomiting, complications and cramps; in extreme instances, extreme fluid consumption may cause seizures or coma.
Right here’s why this occurs. To cease harmful escalations in fever, the physique releases antidiuretic hormones. Urination is diminished, so the physique retains water by means of the actions of the kidneys. So if somebody with a fever drinks extra water than crucial, water intoxication – or hyponatremia, a doubtlessly deadly medical situation through which a affected person’s blood sodium ranges are too low – may comply with.
One examine discovered that almost 1 / 4 of sufferers who got here to the hospital with COVID-19 had hyponatremia upon admission. In that examine, hyponatremia elevated the necessity for respiratory assist within the type of air flow. And one other examine confirmed that the situation can result in poorer outcomes in COVID-19 sufferers.
So perhaps it’s time to rethink the standard knowledge. If the fever is gentle or average, keep heat, even use blankets, reasonably than attempt to actively scale back it. Relaxation, so your physique can battle the fever. Preserve vitality as a result of your metabolism is already on overdrive. Use fever-reducing drugs sparingly. Drink fluids, however solely to tolerance, and ideally when thirsty.
And one closing suggestion that ought to be soothing: When combating a fever or vaccine negative effects, contemplate sipping heat liquids that comprise sodium. Broths containing sodium, like bullion, might assist keep away from hyponatremia. And though the precise scientific proof is sparse and conflicting, hen soup could also be a greater antidote than water when keeping off a fever or flu signs.
Tamara Hew-Butler doesn’t work for, seek the advice of, personal shares in or obtain funding from any firm or group that might profit from this text, and has disclosed no related affiliations past their educational appointment.