Gabrielle Henderson/Unsplash, CC BY
The time period “poisonous positivity” has obtained a great deal of consideration recently. Coming off the again of the “positivity motion” we’re starting to recognise whereas feeling completely satisfied is an effective factor, overemphasising the significance of a constructive angle can backfire, mockingly resulting in extra unhappiness.
Sure, analysis exhibits happier individuals are likely to reside longer, be more healthy and luxuriate in extra profitable lives. And “very completely satisfied individuals” have extra of those advantages relative to solely averagely completely satisfied individuals. However pursued in sure methods, happiness or positivity can develop into poisonous.
Our analysis, revealed in The Journal of Optimistic Psychology and involving virtually 500 individuals, was impressed by these apparently inconsistent findings – pursuing happiness could also be each good and unhealthy for our well-being. We aimed to uncover a key ingredient that turns positivity poisonous.
Learn extra:
The rise of pop-psychology: can it make your life higher, or is all of it snake-oil?
Anticipating the most effective, feeling worse
Some research have proven that when individuals place a excessive worth on their very own happiness it may well result in much less happiness, particularly in contexts the place they most anticipate to really feel completely satisfied.
This tendency to anticipate happiness after which to really feel upset or responsible oneself for not feeling completely satisfied sufficient, has been linked to larger depressive signs and deficits in well-being.
As the road to a cartoon by Randy Glasbergen depicting a affected person confessing to his psychologist places it:
I’m very, very completely satisfied. However I need to be very, very, very completely satisfied, and that’s the reason I’m depressing.
Nevertheless, researchers have additionally noticed when individuals prioritise behaviours that maximise the chance of their future happiness – reasonably than making an attempt to straight improve their ranges of happiness “within the second” – they’re extra prone to expertise enhancements (reasonably than deficits) of their ranges of well-being.
This may increasingly imply partaking in actions that present a way of accomplishment or goal, corresponding to volunteering time or finishing troublesome duties, or developing day by day routines that assist well-being.
This work suggests pursuing happiness not directly, reasonably than making it the primary focus, might flip our seek for positivity from poisonous to tonic.
Unsplash/Ethan Sykes, CC BY
Learn extra:
Coronavirus: tiny moments of enjoyment actually may help us via this irritating time
Valuing happiness vs. prioritising positivity
We wished to seek out out what it was about making happiness a focal purpose that backfires.
To realize a greater understanding, we measured these two approaches to discovering happiness: valuing happiness versus prioritising positivity.
Individuals who valued happiness agreed with statements corresponding to “I’m involved about my happiness even after I really feel completely satisfied” or “If I don’t really feel completely satisfied, possibly there’s something mistaken with me”.
Individuals who prioritised positivity agreed with statements corresponding to “I construction my day to maximise my happiness” or “I search for and nurture my constructive feelings”.
We additionally included a measure of the extent to which individuals really feel uncomfortable with their unfavorable emotional experiences. To do that, we requested for responses to statements like: “I see myself as failing in life when feeling depressed or anxious” or “I like myself much less after I really feel depressed or anxious”.
Individuals who anticipated to really feel completely satisfied (scoring excessive on valuing happiness), additionally tended to see their unfavorable emotional states as an indication of failure in life and lacked acceptance of those emotional experiences. This discomfort with unfavorable feelings partly defined why that they had decrease ranges of well-being.
Then again, individuals who pursued happiness not directly (scoring excessive on prioritising positivity), didn’t see their unfavorable emotional states this manner. They have been extra accepting of low emotions and didn’t see them as an indication they have been failing in life.
What this exhibits is when individuals consider they should preserve excessive ranges of positivity or happiness on a regular basis to make their lives worthwhile, or to be valued by others, they react poorly to their unfavorable feelings. They battle with these emotions or attempt to keep away from them, reasonably than settle for them as a traditional a part of life.
Pursuing happiness not directly doesn’t result in this similar response. Feeling down or pressured is just not inconsistent with discovering happiness.
Courtney Cook dinner/Unsplash, CC BY
Learn extra:
Right here comes the solar: how the climate impacts our temper
What makes positivity poisonous?
So, it seems the important thing ingredient in poisonous positivity is just not positivity itself, in spite of everything. Somewhat, it’s how an individual’s angle to happiness leads them to answer unfavorable experiences in life.
The prospect of experiencing ache, failure, loss, or disappointment in life is unavoidable. There are occasions we’re going to really feel depressed, anxious, fearful, or lonely. It is a truth. What issues is how we reply to those experiences. Can we lean into them and settle for them for what they’re, or will we attempt to keep away from and escape from them?
Learn extra:
Why unhealthy moods are good for you: the stunning advantages of unhappiness
If we’re aiming to be completely satisfied on a regular basis then we’d really feel robust instances are interrupting our purpose. But when we merely put a precedence on positivity, we’re much less involved by these emotions – we see them as an ingredient within the good life and a part of the general journey.
Somewhat than at all times making an attempt to “flip a frown the other way up”, we’re extra prepared to take a seat with our low or uncomfortable feelings and perceive that doing so will, in the long term, make us completely satisfied.
Studying to reply reasonably than react to those feelings is a key enabler of our happiness.
Our response to discomfort is usually to get away and to scale back the ache. This would possibly imply we make use of ineffective emotion regulation methods corresponding to avoiding or suppressing disagreeable emotions.
If we do, we fail to have interaction with the insights an disagreeable experiences deliver. Responding effectively to those experiences means getting “discomfortable” – being snug with our discomfort. Then we may be prepared to really feel what we really feel and get interested in why these feeling are there. Taking this response permits us to extend our understanding, see our selections, and make higher choices.
Because the saying goes: “Ache is inevitable. Struggling is non-compulsory”.
Brock Bastian works for the College of Melbourne and consults to organisations on problems with tradition, ethics, and wellbeing for Psychological Security Australia. He receives funding from the Australian Analysis Council.
Ashley Humphrey doesn’t work for, seek the advice of, personal shares in or obtain funding from any firm or group that may profit from this text, and has disclosed no related affiliations past their tutorial appointment.