Following speedy developments within the sexual abuse lawsuit in opposition to Prince Andrew, Buckingham Palace issued an announcement asserting that Andrew will lose all his remaining patronages and navy titles (comparable to Colonel of the Grenadier Guards). Moreover, he’ll now not use his HRH (“His Royal Highness”) model.
That is an overdue step after Andrew successfully left public life following his disastrous Newsnight interview, the place he unconvincingly tried to handle the allegations of sexual assault levelled in opposition to him by Virginia Giuffre.
In late 2019, some titles and duties had been suspended “for the forseeable future”, creating the chance that Andrew may return to public life sooner or later. Now that the lawsuit in opposition to him is continuing to a trial (except a settlement is reached out of court docket), the palace has determined to take away his titles altogether.
That Prince Andrew won’t ever return to public life is implicit within the palace’s assertion, as all patronages and navy positions will revert again to the Queen. Given the Queen’s age, she is going to probably redistribute them to different members of the royal household.
This choice is just like the one reached with Prince Harry and the Duchess of Sussex in 2019, after they stepped again from their roles as senior royals. Then, the Queen introduced that her grandson and his spouse would now not use the HRH title.
Andrew is now in the identical place, although for fairly completely different causes. Formally, all three retain the HRH title, however is not going to use it in official capability. The problem for the Queen is that each Prince Harry and Prince Andrew are entitled to retain the title underneath Letters Patent issued by George V in 1917 (it is a authorized doc that successfully expresses the desires of the monarch). It might take an additional Letters Patent for a HRH title to be faraway from somebody.
In 1996 this occurred with Diana, Princess of Wales, following her divorce with Prince Charles. This was enormously controversial on the time, however it reveals that it’s doable for somebody to formally lose their HRH title.
The grand previous Duke of York
Nonetheless, Andrew has not misplaced every part. He retains the title of “prince” from start, and stays the Duke of York, which is a peerage. Beneath the regulation, each titles and peerages are types of intangible property (incorporeal hereditaments). A common precept of regulation is that property can’t merely be seized from somebody with out prior authorized authorisation. He additionally stays within the line of succession for the throne.
Once more, we’ve to return to 1917, this time to contemplate the instance of the Titles Deprivation Act. This allowed for peerages and the title of “prince” to be faraway from these “who’ve, in the course of the current warfare, borne arms in opposition to His Majesty or His Allies, or who’ve adhered to His Majesty’s enemies”.
The Duke of Albany, Duke of Cumberland and Teviotdale, and Duke of Brunswick all misplaced their peerages as a result of they had been officers within the German Military in the course of the first world warfare. Equally, for Andrew’s dukedom and title of prince to be eliminated, an act of parliament could be required. That is unlikely to be a precedence for MPs in the mean time.
Chris Allan / Shutterstock
Seeking to the longer term, when Andrew dies, the dukedom will die with him, as he leaves no male inheritor. Historically, the peerage would go to the second eldest son of the monarch (the eldest son turns into Prince of Wales, and the Duke of Cornwall). Maybe when the time comes, Prince Louis might favor one other title to keep away from any affiliation along with his nice uncle.
Andrew additionally retains the place of Councillor of State. Ought to the Queen be unable to fulfil her formal authorized duties on account of sickness, Councillors of State can fulfil these duties on her behalf. That is supplied for by the Regency Acts 1937 to 1953, which specify that the primary 4 within the line of succession of full age (which on this case is 21 not 18), are appointed as Councillors. That at present means Prince Charles, Prince William, Prince Harry and Prince Andrew. Two are anticipated to behave collectively, which if required, could be Prince Charles and Prince William. Once more, for this to alter, an act of parliament could be required.
There are different issues with the Regency Acts, making reform extra probably within the close to future, particularly when Prince Charles turns into King. This may create the chance to extra completely tackle the place of each Prince Harry and Prince Andrew.
The dukedom and Andrew’s place as a Councillor of State imply that the separation of Prince Andrew from royal life just isn’t totally full, however it’s so far as the Queen can go for now. The remaining is as much as Parliament.
What did you consider this text?
Nice | Good | Meh | Weak
Craig Prescott doesn’t work for, seek the advice of, personal shares in or obtain funding from any firm or organisation that will profit from this text, and has disclosed no related affiliations past their tutorial appointment.