The UK authorities is battening down the hatches for a wave of strikes in December and January. Railway staff, nurses, ambulance staff, civil servants and postal employees are all set to take industrial motion within the coming weeks in protest at wages not maintaining with inflation, with lecturers’ and firefighters’ unions additionally balloting their members.
Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has put shut ally Oliver Dowden accountable for a brand new process power to coordinate the federal government’s response to so many teams of staff. With rail employees, college lecturers, postal staff and legal barristers having already taken to the picket traces, the federal government is making an attempt to keep away from one other winter of discontent.
Jim Callaghan’s Labour administration by no means recovered from the disaster of winter 1978-79. He misplaced the final election a couple of months later and his get together spent 18 years in opposition.
So how related is the present state of affairs to that debacle, and what are the federal government’s possibilities of stopping historical past repeating itself?
The social contract
Like right now, the UK was going through an vitality provide disaster and excessive inflation when Labour got here to energy within the mid-Nineteen Seventies. It responded with an IMF mortgage, public spending cuts and a “social contract”, the place the commerce unions restrained wage calls for in return for insurance policies like lease freezes and meals subsidies.
Wikimedia, CC BY-SA
This saved pay rises minimal till 1978, serving to to cut back inflation from over 20% to round 8%-10% by the point Labour left workplace. Nevertheless, staff obtained poorer in consequence: wages fell 13% in actual phrases (that means relative to costs) between 1975 and 1980.
Likewise in current months, many staff have been supplied offers within the area of three% to five% – far wanting right now’s 11% annual inflation. Employees in sectors taking industrial motion have seen actual wages decreased by 3% in each the second and third quarters.
In 1978, when Callaghan tried to cap wage will increase at 5% for the 12 months forward, the commerce unions had had sufficient. The Trades Union Congress (TUC) publicly opposed the cap that July.
The cap was then examined by Ford staff on the Halewood plant close to Liverpool within the September. Backed by the Transport and Common Employees Union, they took half in eight weeks of business motion to power a greater deal. The automotive producer finally gave them 17%.
The federal government tried to sanction Ford, however in December the Conservatives efficiently handed a parliamentary movement revoking the transfer. Although the federal government narrowly survived a vote of no confidence, it deserted the cap.
This was the second the flood gates opened. Between November 1978 and February 1979, throughout a freezing chilly winter, 4.6 million staff went on strike together with in rail, water, bakeries, haulage, nursing, ambulances, grave digging and refuse assortment.
Labour wasn’t working
The federal government endured humiliation after humiliation. In response to industrial motion by oil tanker drivers, it threatened to mobilise the military to maintain tankers transferring. But drivers nonetheless finally obtained a 15% pay rise.
Highway haulage staff went one higher, declining a 15% pay improve to safe 20% after a protracted strike. On seeing these non-public sector successes, public sector staff upped the ante. On January 22, a nationwide “day of motion” noticed 1.5 million of them stroll out.
All through this era, Margaret Thatcher’s Conservatives criticised the strikes whereas additionally refusing to help the federal government’s pay cap. In March, Thatcher managed to steer a majority of MPs to vote no confidence in Callaghan’s authorities. After profitable energy, she later restricted commerce union actions, benefiting from the truth that 84% of individuals thought they’d grown too highly effective.
The current day
The 2022 Conservatives face the identical mixture of widespread strikes, excessive inflation and falling reputation that Labour confronted in 1978. Additionally they have the extra problem of a recession, making it even more durable to resolve wage disputes.
Labour additionally faces a further complication in its historic hyperlinks with the commerce unions. To reassure the general public that he’s not of their pockets, get together chief Keir Starmer banned his shadow cupboard from visiting picket traces in the summertime, regardless of pledging to work “shoulder to shoulder with commerce unions” throughout his 2020 management marketing campaign.
He then sacked a junior minister, Sam Tarry, in July for disobeying the foundations. But senior get together figures have since challenged the coverage and obtained away with it. Starmer clearly has to tread an ungainly line between interesting to his rank and file and interesting to the nation.
Over the winter, Starmer’s method is probably going to learn by public opinion. One vital characteristic of the winter of discontent was the commerce unions overplaying their hand and finally shedding the help of the general public.
To date in 2022, the general public have been torn. A YouGov ballot in June instructed they supported medical doctors, nurses, firefighters and lecturers doubtlessly taking motion, however opposed strikes by bus drivers, college employees, civil servants and barristers.
Extra just lately the general public have sympathised with public-sector staff receiving below-inflation pay provides, significantly throughout the NHS. Postal staff have additionally just lately loved sturdy help, although rail staff haven’t.
In an echo of Ford’s 17% settlement in 1978, the unions can be taking a look at current wage agreements for legal barristers (15%) and BT (as much as 16%) as potential benchmarks. Public sector staff – having largely staffed Britain’s pandemic response – look unlikely to accept sub-inflation wage will increase given their overwhelming help for motion in current strike ballots. Equally, nevertheless, I query whether or not the federal government will be capable to provide such offers given the state of the nation’s funds.
It’s subsequently troublesome to see this resolving simply. The federal government’s new process power seems unlikely to unravel the issue: it’s solely making an attempt to mitigate the influence of business motion, moderately than negotiating higher offers.
Confronted with dismal polling scores, Rishi Sunak is going through a disaster with quite a few parallels to the winter of discontent. As the subsequent wave of strikes will get underway, it appears a close to insurmountable process to keep away from a repeat of the 1978/79 unrest. To say the least, the federal government is in a really troublesome place.
Christopher Massey is a Labour Occasion Councillor for Redcar and Cleveland Borough Council.